iPhone or Bark Phone for a first smartphone?

You can set up either phone for calls, texts and location sharing, then add capabilities as your child needs them. For most parents, I think Bark Phone is the better choice: it's easier to use, it's tamper-proof, and its settings are much less likely to turn off or change on their own.

Bark Phone is available only in the US, so outside the US I'd go with an iPhone configured for a child. If you're still choosing between a watch and a phone, my phone-readiness guide will help with that decision.

My short answer

  • I'd choose Bark Phone for its monitoring, or for powerful, tamper-proof controls that are straightforward to manage.
  • An iPhone is a good choice if you have one available to use or you live outside the US. Apple's built-in controls give you a lot of flexibility, with more work to set them up and keep them checked.

Do you want monitoring?

Bark Phone checks texts, photos, videos and supported app activity for concerns such as bullying, depression and sexual content. When Bark flags a conversation, the alert shows a snippet. For flagged photos and videos, Bark includes a copy unless the content may contain child nudity. If a photo is flagged for that reason, the alert shows a blank placeholder.

In my review, I sent messages about depression. Bark flagged them within 30 minutes and showed me the messages it identified as concerning.

Text monitoring is included even if you start with just calls and texts. As you allow apps, monitoring coverage depends on the app and the activity within it. You can also connect supported email and other online accounts. Bark analyzes this content on its servers.

Apple's Communication Safety warns children about sensitive photos and videos, including nudity. Bark's monitoring covers a broader range of concerns and sends alerts to parents.

How much setup and upkeep do you want?

Apple's controls let you choose who your child can call and text, which apps and websites they can use, and when they can use the phone. You can make an iPhone into a very limited device and adjust those choices over time. The settings are spread across several menus, so setting it up takes more work.

Bark Phone's setup was straightforward when I reviewed it. You manage the phone through the Bark parent app, where you can approve contacts and apps, set schedules and adjust what your child can access.

The difference continues after setup. On an iPhone, I'd recheck the controls after each software update. Bark Phone uses mobile device management, the technology companies use to manage employees' phones. Bark is built into the phone, and changing protected settings requires a code from your Bark parent app. If a setting Bark needs is disabled, the phone blocks internet access until you restore that setting. Its managed controls don't need the same routine of rechecking after each update.

That reduced upkeep can be enough reason to choose Bark Phone, even if monitoring isn't your main reason for buying it.

What else favors an iPhone?

If you already own an iPhone your child can use, reusing it saves the cost of another device.

An iPhone has FaceTime built in for video calls. To join a FaceTime call on Bark Phone, your child needs a browser link and permission to use the browser. Bark Phone can still call and text iPhones.

Start with what your child needs

If the phone is for staying in touch after school, I'd start with calls and texts to approved contacts, plus location sharing. Then I'd add capabilities one at a time as your child needs them and is ready to use them. Sometimes that might mean allowing something temporarily for a particular purpose.

Both phones can grow with your child. Bark Phone's calls-and-texts plan is called Starter. It includes monitoring, location tracking and contact approvals. When you want to add apps or web access, you can switch the same phone to an Advanced plan and choose what to allow. On an iPhone, you add capabilities through the settings you've already set up.

What will it cost?

For an iPhone, budget for the phone and your carrier's service plan. Apple's controls are included. You can use a phone you already own or buy one. In the US, a new iPhone from Apple starts at $699 for the iPhone 17e; prices and carrier plans vary by country.

Bark Phone uses Bark's own wireless service. The standard Bark Phone costs $360, paid once, and you can also pay for it over time at checkout. Each US service plan includes unlimited calls and texts:

PlanInternet access for apps and browsingMonthly service
StarterNo apps or browsing$29
Advanced, Wi-Fi onlyOn Wi-Fi$39
Advanced, 4 GBOn Wi-Fi and mobile data$49

If I were adding apps, I'd consider the Wi-Fi-only plan first. Calls and texts still work away from Wi-Fi; browsing and apps that need internet access work when the phone is connected to Wi-Fi.

Setting up the phone you choose

My iPhone Parental Controls Masterclass walks you through setting up an iPhone for your child. You'll understand what each setting does and why you might choose it, so you can explain those choices to your child too.

For Bark Phone, my review and setup guide shows the settings I'd change before handing it over. Discount code FAMILYITGUY takes $30 off the phone's purchase price, not the monthly service fee. Buy a Bark Phone with the FAMILYITGUY discount.

I earn a commission if you purchase through the Bark buying link above, at no extra cost to you.